Skin Clinic Guide
Side profile of a woman with deep brown skin and short curly hair wearing a large gold hoop earring against a taupe backdrop

Safety and rules

Piercing bump or keloid? How to tell the difference

Most piercing bumps are irritation, infection or a raised scar that settles. Keloids grow beyond the wound. How they differ, who gets them and when to see a GP.

A bump next to a new piercing is usually irritation, an infection, an allergy to the metal or a raised scar that stays within the piercing area and tends to settle with time. A keloid is different: it is a firm, often shiny scar that keeps growing beyond the original wound, sometimes months or years later, and it does not usually go away on its own. Keloids are more common in people with darker skin. Only a doctor can tell you for certain which one you have, so see a GP if a bump is growing, painful or worrying you.

The main types of piercing bump

“Piercing bump” is not a medical term. It is used for several different problems, which the dermatology reference site DermNet describes in its guide to body piercing complications.

Infection

DermNet says infection is more likely with deep piercings and those through mucous membranes, such as the inside of the mouth. The NHS says signs of an infected piercing include the area being swollen, painful, hot, “very red or dark (depending on your skin colour)”, bleeding or leaking pus, or feeling unwell. It advises getting medical help if you think your piercing is infected, and to leave your jewellery in unless a doctor tells you to take it out (NHS: infected piercings).

Allergy to the jewellery

DermNet says allergic contact dermatitis is the most common non-infectious skin problem with piercings, and nickel is the most common cause. Surgical stainless steel, titanium, niobium or gold are suggested, especially while a piercing heals (DermNet).

Granuloma

A granuloma is a lump of inflamed tissue reacting to something the body sees as foreign. DermNet lists foreign body granuloma as a piercing complication that a doctor can treat.

Hypertrophic scar

A hypertrophic scar is a thick, raised scar that stays within the area of the original wound. After piercing, DermNet says these usually appear four to eight weeks after the injury, can grow for up to six months, and then flatten over a few years (DermNet). They are “more likely to regress and resolve” than keloids (DermNet: keloid and hypertrophic scar).

Keloid

The NHS describes a keloid as “a raised scar left on the skin after a wound has healed”, which can follow any skin injury, including “a body piercing” (NHS: keloid scars). The British Association of Dermatologists (BAD) says a keloid “overgrows and becomes larger than the original wound”, and lists ear piercing as a known trigger, with the earlobes and chest as high-risk areas (BAD: keloids).

Piercing bump vs keloid: how to tell the difference

These are general patterns from the sources above, not a way to diagnose yourself.

Hypertrophic scar or irritation bump Keloid
Where it grows Stays within the piercing area Spreads beyond the original wound
When it appears Usually within weeks Can appear months or years later
What happens over time Often flattens or settles Usually persists and may keep growing
How it feels May be tender or sore Firm, smooth, shiny; may itch or hurt while growing

The NHS says a keloid usually grows “for months or years” and becomes bigger than the original wound, and may be itchy or painful while it grows (NHS). DermNet adds that keloids “can arise months to years after an injury” and tend to persist (DermNet).

Treatments for Keloid Scars: Q&A with a dermatologist|Dr Dray, from Dr Dray on YouTube

Darker and melanin-rich skin

Keloids can happen to anyone, but they are not evenly spread. The NHS lists people of “south Asian, Chinese, African Caribbean or Black African origin” as more likely to get them, along with people aged 10 to 30, people who are pregnant and anyone who has had a keloid before (NHS). The BAD says keloids are “more common in skin of colour” (BAD skin of colour), and DermNet says they are more frequent in skin types III to VI (DermNet). The cause is not fully understood, but the BAD explains that keloids involve the skin making too much collagen, and the tendency can run in families.

Two other points matter for darker skin:

  • Colour after healing. Darker skin is more likely to develop dark marks after inflammation, called post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. These usually fade, but slowly (BAD skin of colour). A dark mark around a piercing is not the same as a keloid. Our guide to hyperpigmentation explains why.
  • Treatment side effects. The BAD warns that cryotherapy (freezing) can cause loss of skin pigment (BAD). Lighter patches tend to be more noticeable on darker skin. Ask about this before any treatment.

If you have had a keloid before, the NHS advises avoiding tattoos and piercings, and treating acne early to reduce scarring.

When to see a GP

See a GP if:

  • a bump is getting bigger, spreading beyond the piercing, or has appeared months after the piercing healed
  • it is itchy, painful or bothering you
  • you think you have had a keloid before

The NHS says early treatment of a keloid “may help stop the keloid scar growing” (NHS). A GP can refer you to a dermatologist if needed.

Get urgent advice from a GP or NHS 111 if a piercing looks infected, especially if you feel hot, shivery or unwell. A pharmacist can advise on silicone scar gels and dressings, which the BAD says are available without prescription.

Treatment options

There is no single cure for keloids, and the BAD says no one treatment is clearly better than the others. Options a GP or dermatologist may discuss include:

  • Steroid injections. The most common treatment, often repeated monthly for four to six months. They can flatten a keloid, but the BAD says “up to 50% of keloids grow back”, and steroids can thin or lighten the skin.
  • Steroid cream. Listed by the NHS as an option.
  • Silicone gels or dressings. The BAD says these are safe and can be bought from a pharmacist without prescription. They are used for several months.
  • Pressure. Compression with clips or splints may help, especially on earlobes (BAD).
  • Cryotherapy. Freezing, alone or with other treatments; risk of losing skin pigment.
  • Laser. Can help, especially combined with steroid injections, according to the BAD.
  • Surgery. The NHS says removal is not usually recommended because the scar is likely to come back bigger. When surgeons do remove ear keloids, it is usually combined with other treatment. A 2016 review of 25 studies on ear keloids found recurrence rates of 15.4% when removal was followed by steroid injections and 14.0% when followed by radiotherapy (Shin et al, Plast Reconstr Surg 2016). A 2024 review found removal combined with steroids or radiotherapy did better than removal alone (Huang et al, Aesthetic Plast Surg 2024).
  • Radiotherapy. Sometimes used after surgery, but the BAD says it is rarely used because it “carries a small risk of causing skin cancer”.

Keloid treatment is medical treatment, not a beauty service. Be cautious about salons or online sellers offering to “remove” keloids, or creams promising to dissolve them. For general advice on checking who treats you, see our guide to choosing a skin clinic, and for how cosmetic treatment is regulated, our regulation guide.

Questions people ask

Is my piercing bump a keloid?

Most bumps that appear in the first weeks are irritation, infection, an allergy or a hypertrophic scar that stays within the piercing area. A bump that keeps growing past the edges of the piercing, or appears months later, is more likely to be a keloid. A GP can tell you which.

Can a keloid on the ear go away on its own?

Keloids usually persist. DermNet says they tend to persist without resolving on their own, which is why treatment is often needed if one bothers you.

Should I take my earring out?

If a piercing might be infected, the NHS says to leave the jewellery in unless a doctor tells you to remove it. Removing it can trap infection. If you think the metal is causing an allergy, ask a pharmacist or GP before switching.

What about a keloid on a nose piercing?

The same rules apply. DermNet notes that piercings through cartilage heal poorly because of its limited blood supply. Any growing lump should be checked by a GP.

Can I get pierced again after a keloid?

The NHS advises people at higher risk, including anyone who has had a keloid before, to avoid piercings. A dermatologist can advise on your own risk.

Can a clinic treat my keloid?

Keloids are treated by GPs, dermatologists and surgeons. Ask about the practitioner’s qualifications and how they would reduce the chance of the keloid coming back, and check their registration before treatment. Prices for cosmetic treatments vary; see our price guide.

General information from the sources linked on this page, not medical advice. Results vary from person to person. For a new or changing skin problem, see your GP or a pharmacist first.

Photo credits

Photos: RootedColors via Nappy, CC0 1.0 Universal (public domain dedication); Direct Media via StockSnap, CC0 1.0 Universal (public domain dedication); Authentic Stock via StockSnap, CC0 1.0 Universal (public domain dedication); Direct Media via StockSnap, CC0 1.0 Universal (public domain dedication)